header
QM logo in partnership with agena logo
Providing Outreach  in Computer Science Bringing Bayesian solutions to real-world risk problems

Probability: Fallacies, Myths and Puzzles: Main Page

Probabilistic Card Trick (Wrong Solution)


The number of different possible arrangements of 52 cards is 52!
(= 52 x 51 x 50 x … x 3 x 2 x 1).
That’s because there are 52 ways you can choose the first card, 51 ways to choose the second card (once the first is chosen) 50 ways to choose the third once the first two are chosen, etc).


Now, let’s suppose the chosen cards are Queen (Q) and King (K) (the following argument works irrespective of what the values are).  The first thing we need to think about is how many ways we can arrange a Q and K consecutively.

There are 4 four Q’s (Qc, Qs, Qh, Qd) and four K’s (Kc, Ks, Ks, Kd).

This means there are 8 ways involving the Queen of Spades (Qs):

QsKs    KsQs    QsKc    KcQs    QsKd    KdQs    QsKh    KhQs

Similarly there are 8 ways involving each of the other three Qs. Hence the total number of ways to arrange a Q and K consecutively in two fixed positions is 32. But there are 51 such fixed positions, namely positions (1,2), (2,3), (3,4) … (51, 52) in the deck. And for EACH of these fixed positions there are 50! Ways in which the remaining 50 cards can be arranged.

That means there are 32 x 51 x 50!  possible arrangements of the cards in which a Q and K appear consecutively.

So the probability of a Q and K appearing consecutively is simply this number divided by the total number of possible arrangements, i.e.

(32 x 51 x 50!)/ 52! = 32/52 = 0.61



footer
Norman Fenton


Return to Main Page Making Sense of Probability: Fallacies, Myths and Puzzles